If SEO Dies, Will Search Engines Be Mortally Wounded

Writing by Nick Stamoulis on Friday, 9 of May , 2008 at 6:33 am

Search Engine Optimization is dying, at least according to Greg Howlett, writing on Andy Beal’s Marketing Pilgrim site. I can agree with much of what he has written and some of his points are quite valid. Take the following:

Search engines are too smart and they have a different agenda. They do not want to reward crummy companies that play SEO games–they want to give the top listings to the best companies.

It is hard to argue with that point particularly if you are a web user who gets a little tired of the useless results when doing a search. The last part of that statement worries me a little, but I will return to that a little later. If you are an SEO consultant then naturally you want to see any site you work on get to that front page of SERP’s.

What I or Greg think is a crummy site, I am sure there others including the site owners who think otherwise. If I am hired as an Search Engine Optimization consultant, do I say ’sorry, your site is too crummy’. Perhaps trying to get the site owner to de-crumify the site may be in order.

Putting that issue aside, the following statement is the one that really concerns me.

If you are not in the top ten of your industry, you had better find a way to get there in a hurry if you want to be on the first page of Google.

Greg also added:

Yes, this means that the rich will get richer and the poor will starve for SEO traffic. If you are not in the first category, you had better find a way to get there quick. The middle class is about to disappear.

The reason this concerns me, and the reason for my title is very simple. Big companies that are in the top ten do not rely on search engines for their traffic. In fact if your lazy like me, I type my search phrase in to the URL bar. If my search is for something simple like Coke or Pepsi - it will take me straight to their site, do not pass Google, do not collect Yahoo!. This is true for most large companies that are well recognized. I don’t know how much effort Coke or Pepsi put into Search Engine Optimization? Very little I would suggest.

If the search engines are going ignore popular little sites and list the “top ten of your industry“, search engines will become redundant. I don’t need Google or Yahoo! or any of the others search engines to find these companies. Their URL’s are generally either known, or easy to find. To them, SEO can die, they don’t need it.

The ramifications will spread further. If my Search Engine Optimization efforts have little hope of making it to the front pages of Google, then I doubt I will be advertising there. Social media sites will become more popular as advertising venues. This will strike a mortal wound at the very heart of Google - their advertising revenue.

Search engines and Search Engine Optimization live in a symbiotic relationship - if one goes then the other will be severely affected. The future will see the role of an SEO consultant change, but then, over the last 10 years that role has gone through many changes. I can see the value of keywords disappearing as search engines rely more on being able to ‘read’ content and context.

If search engines do put an end to Search Engine Optimization by concentrating on the top ten in any business sector, they will have taken the first step in their own demise. Search engines do, and will, need to produce better search results, until they do, SEO will be a requirement for every web site owner looking for that prime spot in the SERP’s.

Category: SEO

• Add this post to Del.icio.us - Digg